When jokingly speaking with my friend, Lucy Agnes, we got into a kind-of agreeing debate. She remarked that women had no high standards, but really ought to. And I said in agreement this: if Juliet has no balcony for Romeo to climb, then how does she know he loves her enough to climb it if she did? And at the time, I didn't think much about it. But now, as I ponder the subject more, I think how terribly true it is. We don't have any balconies. We don't even have any garden steps. Some of us have even sunk so low as to not even have a door in the way. And it's so sad. See, really, my protest here is about men, but I have to begin with someone else. The ones allowing it to happen - women. Everywhere I look in the world, women are debasing themselves for no reason. What happened to the days where a romance wen like this:
Lady is high above gentleman. He loves her and wants to make her know. So he tries. And fails. And tries again. And again. And again. And again. He does everything in his power to make her come down to him. But then he realizes that he must not let her stoop down - he must come up. So he climbs, and climbs, and climbs - up to her. And finally, he is admitted.
Now, some may think this sounds stuffy, but it's a whole lot better than this:
It's very sad. I hope in this comparison I have made my case concerning the part of women. Now to tackle the main subject.
Writers, ask yourself this: have I ever described men in a debasing way in my stories? Made a supposed to be sympathetic male character with no backbone, or who is effeminate? Made my leading man whiny, unintelligent, angry, or unsteady, while my villain was masculine and clever? Have I ever made my leading lady throw herself away in the hope of getting said leading man without ever regretting it? Have I viewed or described a childish leading man in my story as a good or ideal man?
If you answer yes to any of these questions without good reason, then I'm afraid you too may have fallen to the trend. What is it with us writers, then? Why is it that in the movies and books we get heroes like Harry Potter, Captain Jack Sparrow, and Iron Man? People who could care less about anyone other than themselves, even though they (with the exception of Captain Sparrow) make pretense of being heroic? They care about nothing but their own acclaimed heroism, glory, and good name (and sometimes not even that). If somebody despises them, they don't just get over it. They despise the person back; insulting them and tricking them in whatever way possible (examples: Harry Potter always making fun of his unpleasant cousin Dudley; Captain Jack trying to double-cross Barbossa, Will, and Elizabeth constantly; Iron Man making crude jokes about whatever villain he's facing, not to mention Cap as well).
And not only that, but if they ever 'reform', it's only half way. And the writer sticks with them. Rowling often supports Harry in his poking fun at Dudley by agreeing that Dudley is fat, not so good-looking, and not incredibly clever. And what do we see in Jack's friends but people who not only deserve to be tricked, but also would backstab Jack as well on the turn of a dime? And how many Marvel fans and even Marvel makers out there are saying that Cap just needs to 'loosen up' about Iron Man? Loosen up on what? Loosen up on being a hero, on being a real man? The type that would give his life for even the random, villainous henchman who most heroes would say doesn't deserve to live? The type that would put his all into even the smallest acts, and never let go of what he believed if he knew it was good, true, or beautiful? The type that never disrespected boundaries that other people set unless said boundaries endangered someone? The type that could possibly want to remain true to the same girl for 70 years, and even afterwards, when she's dead, take her over anyone else were she still there?
And then there's Iron Man. The only heroism in him is the instinct to take glory and save lives because it makes him look like a hero. The only manhood in him is the cold definition of manhood - simply being an adult male. Iron Man doesn't even make pretense of giving up his life for people who have hurt him. He would be the one saying that the villain doesn't deserve to live. Iron Man even fights to save the world haphazardly, without plan and on whatever impulse or clever notion he thinks he has. And Iron Man only sticks to his beliefs (what beliefs he has) when they involve his oh-so precious ego. Not even to mention his habits of being a terribly unfaithful jerk.
So what is it with writers then? Why do we write these things? Well, it's a simple answer. It's because that's how things really are in real life. So we write what we see. It's another symptom of modern times - that realisticism in writing that is obsessed with making things out right down to the speck of dust realistic. No goodness, no beauty, just the singled-out dirtiest and most horrific facts. No art to writing anymore is there because of this. However, while I do have quite the bone to pick with realisticist writers (and I know 'realisticist' is not a real word, ironically enough), I shall deal with them another day. But they have helped cause this problem. The problem in society is caused by the fact that we don't want it to change. Obviously we don't, because we just write about what we see and think that's totally okay. We write these anti-heroes who never really change, these playboys who never really reform, and these male feminist wimps we would like to call men. We need to write not as things are - for that is a terrible, mottled thing in these days - but as things should be. A problem will never be solved if we are willing to just live with it.
So today, I have a challenge - a call to arms for all courageous writers out there. Today, just write one hero - a real hero. A man who knows himself, and - even despite struggles - can win over his dark side. A man who is true, good, and beautiful in the truest sense of those words. A man who is willing to climb those balconies and mount those obstacles. A man who is willing to stand strong like a mountain in the midst of a raging blizzard. A man who protects those he loves, and even those who don't love him, without credit or reward or glory. A man who does not give way to women in strength. A man who doesn't speak words of poison. A man who doesn't pitch temper-tantrums or whine or brood. A man who is not some macho braggart either. A man who takes full responsibility, uncomplaining, for all his actions, even when he knows he was wrong. A man who is just doing the right thing. Don't write the Duke of Mantua. Don't write Iron Man. Write instead Nemerino, or Captain America. A hero. Today, writers, write a man who is really a man.
What do you think? Will you respond to my call to arms? Please, take up your pen and respond to this call, much needed in these times! Every hero, no matter how small, will help in this quest. Just remember that, in artfully writing virtue - though the world is against you - you are never alone. Stand with me, writers.
ReplyDeleteI like to see stories about real men- but better yet when I see their development. I loved seeing Narnia's Edmund go from traitor to 'King Edmund the Just'; Tales of Goldstone Wood's Foxbrush trading a wimpy nature for a kingly nature; the Wingfeather Saga's Janner grumbling against his brother in book two, then remaining faithful toward his brother to the last in book four.
There is a journey involved in maturity. So I don't mind negative traits, as long as those traits will be shed along the way.
But I'd also like to point out that the heroes mentioned all had an encounter with their story world's God-figure. They grew out of their faulty and immature natures, but they had help. I think this reflects real life- the death of the old nature when finding God.
I think in this way we can have real men, real heroes, and it will still be realistic.
Yes, and Edmund is a prime example of real masculine development.
DeleteYes. The main problem with conversion stories is that it is rare that the conversion is more than halfway. their immaturity never seems to really go away from them. But a true conversion story is very enjoyable and wholesome.
Yes! I agree. And we should never be afraid to write something just because it may not be seen as realistic - a fairy tale is not abandoned because it has fairies, so neither should we abandon stories of heroes because heroes are now scarce. I recommend looking up the chapter concerning masculinity in Anthony Esolen's excellent book, "Out Of The Ashes". It was a great inspiration to this post.
I love this, Belle! Ha! That was a great conversation we had, and I was thrilled to see it continued in blog post form. :) Yes to real men! Masculinity is something that's been undermined in our current culture. I think the blame lies on women as much as it does on men, because as you pointed out, if we don't have high standards and stick to them, why should a man bother to be a hero?
ReplyDeleteAlso, I adored the references to Iron Man and Captain America, because we just watched The Avengers for practically the first time the night before I found this lovely post. Iron Man's line "Everything special about you came out of a bottle" made me so annoyed with him, because the whole point of Captain America is that what's *really* special about him is what he had BEFORE his powers came out of a bottle. It was only because he was a good man that he became a superhero. And in the climax of Captain America: The First Avenger, his last and most heroic act--putting the plane down so no one would get hurt--was something he could and would have done regardless of his abilities. In that last scene, it was Steve Rogers who was the hero.
Wow. That...turned into a fangirl rant really quickly...
Haha, it was too good to not let the world know about it. :)
DeleteExactly! Not to mention, today women are always trying to fill up the places of men, which leaves men nowhere. That's another problem with today's writers - they write 'strong female characters' who are merely Little Miss Sass bundled up with a machine gun to push her brother out of the way in the world.
Haha, yes, the Avenger. GRRRRRR! You have no idea how mad that comment of his made me the first time I watched Avengers. Exactly! Besides, the only special thing about Iron Man came out of a computer - and that statement's actually true.
Haha, we're all fangirls here, Luce... ;)
^^^This post. I agree with it completely, thank you!
ReplyDeleteThank you! :D
Delete